
#17 Theism and the Weight of Time Why I struggle with the argument from design I am not a militant atheist. But from time to time, I encounter a particular argument from friends—delivered with sincerity, even emotion—that I find difficult to accept. The argument goes something like this: Look at this amazing world we live in. Its beauty, its complexity, its intricacy—surely it must be evidence of a supreme being, an intelligent designer. The world could not possibly exist without one. It’s an argument that has a certain intuitive appeal. I admire it, I respect it, and in some ways, I even envy it. But when I look more closely, the reasoning does not hold up. The Weight of Deep Time Science and paleontology tell a different story. The earliest evidence of Homo sapiens dates back about 300,000 years. That may seem like a long time—until we place it against Earth’s history. Life has existed here for roughly 3.7 billion years before the appearance of humans. That is an unfathomable stretc...